Jio Financial Services Ltd: The $19 Billion Valuation Puzzle

Reliance Industries Ltd. recently spun off its financial services segment into a separate company, Jio Financial Services Ltd. This move, intended to safeguard the company’s inclusion in major global indices, resulted in an eye-catching valuation of over $19 billion. However, the market’s exuberance in assigning such a high valuation to a company shrouded in mystery raises several questions. In this article, we delve into the reasons behind Jio Financial Services Ltd.’s lofty valuation and explore whether the market is putting the cart before the horse.

One of the most puzzling aspects of Jio Financial Services Ltd.’s valuation is the lack of transparency regarding its business operations. The company’s information memorandum filed with stock exchanges provides little insight into the nature of its activities. Despite this opacity, every brokerage seems to agree on a substantial valuation ranging from $19 billion to $22 billion, based primarily on its perceived future potential. This optimism stems from the strong backing of Reliance Industries Ltd. and a well-established board and management team, led by the renowned financial expert, KV Kamath, former Chairman of ICICI Bank Ltd.

Jio Financial Services Ltd.’s subsidiaries hint at a diverse range of financial services it plans to enter. These include retail lending, asset management in collaboration with BlackRock, insurance (both life and non-life), and digital payments. However, the lack of a clear roadmap and detailed business plans leaves both investors and analysts in the dark.

Entering the financial services sector, especially lending and insurance, is not without its challenges. Jio Financial Services Ltd. is expected to commence operations with consumer durable and merchant lending, working capital, and small-ticket business loans for SMEs. Scaling up in this space can be arduous, as SMEs often require a wide array of services, from bank guarantees to overdrafts. Moreover, the company’s current size and employee count are minuscule compared to its competitors in the industry. While it boasts a substantial consolidated net worth, a significant portion is tied up in its stake in Reliance Industries Ltd., limiting its lending capacity.

In its asset management venture, Jio Financial Services Ltd. and BlackRock have pledged to invest $150 million each. However, the mutual fund business is fiercely competitive, and building a distribution network is no walk in the park. The payment bank partnership with SBI and account aggregator business face challenges too, with regulatory restrictions and a lack of a clear business model.

The insurance sector is a long-term play that typically takes at least a decade to achieve meaningful scale. Unless Jio Financial Services Ltd. acquires an existing insurer, it will face an uphill battle in this space. Insurance brokerage is highly competitive, especially with bancassurance channels holding an edge. The question that looms large is whether the market’s eagerness to assign such a high valuation to Jio Financial Services Ltd. is justified. The lack of transparency regarding the company’s business operations and strategy is a red flag. Investors and analysts are left to speculate about the company’s future prospects, which is far from ideal. While the Reliance pedigree and strong leadership are undeniable assets, they cannot compensate for the absence of a clear business plan.

In conclusion, the $19-22 billion valuation of Jio Financial Services Ltd. appears to be a bet on its potential rather than its current reality. As the company gradually reveals its plans and executes its strategy, the market will have a clearer picture of whether this valuation is justified or if it’s indeed putting the cart before the horse. Transparency and communication from the company’s management will be key to reassuring investors and justifying the market’s high expectations.

Startup Funding Summary

IndoSpace, Mumbai-based logistics company, has raised $150 Mn in a funding from Qatar Investment Authority and Grosvenor’s Diversified Property Investments – Read More

Ola Electric, Bangalore-based electric mobility startup, has raised $140 Mn in a funding from Temasek – Read More

Ather Energy, Bangalore-based electric mobility startup, has raised $108 Mn in a funding from Hero MotoCorp and GIC – Read More

Pepperfry, Mumbai-based furniture marketplace, has raised $23 Mn in a funding from HNIs – Read More

Captain Fresh, Bangalore-based seafood supplier, has raised $20 Mn in Series C funding from SBI Investment, Evolvence Capital, Accel, Matrix Partners India, Prosus Ventures and Tiger Global – Read More

M&A Snippets

Delhi-based F & B company Good To Go has acquired Chennai-based F & B startup TenderCuts for an undisclosed amount – Read More